Translation of Supreme Court rulings applying ECJ judgment of 19 November 2019 – Rule of Law

Translation of Supreme Court rulings applying ECJ judgment of 19 November 2019

Share

Rule of Law

Everything you need to know about the rule of law in Poland

More

Court of Justice holds that domestic courts are to review the independence of the new National Council of the Judiciary and the Disciplinary Chamber

The Supreme Court press service has just released an English translation of two rulings dealing with this issue: one by the Labour Law and Social Security Chamber, which requested the ECJ, and the new Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber, to which a question of law was posed by a 3-judge panel of this body.

Discrepancies in the case law of the top court present in these judgments led to the landmark resolution of three Supreme Court chambers of 23 January 2020, following the motion of the First President of the Supreme Court. An English translation of this resolution, including the full grounds, is expected in a few days.

[by Patryk Wachowiec]

Author

Rule of Law

Everything you need to know about the rule of law in Poland

More

Published

February 9, 2020

Tags

Supreme Court Poland Constitutional Tribunal Disciplinary Chamber judges rule of law disciplinary proceedings Zbigniew Ziobro National Council of the Judiciary judicial independence Court of Justice of the EU European Commission European Union Andrzej Duda Małgorzata Manowska Court of Justice Minister of Justice European Court of Human Rights Adam Bodnar Igor Tuleya disciplinary system neo-judges muzzle law CJEU Jarosław Kaczyński National Recovery Plan Mateusz Morawiecki Commissioner for Human Rights Waldemar Żurek Court of Justice of the European Union National Council for Judiciary Przemysław Radzik democracy Piotr Schab judiciary presidential elections elections criminal law Kamil Zaradkiewicz elections 2023 disciplinary commissioner media freedom Julia Przyłębska K 3/21 First President of the Supreme Court elections 2020 harassment Supreme Administrative Court preliminary rulings Dagmara Pawełczyk-Woicka prosecution Hungary Michał Lasota prosecutors Beata Morawiec Recovery Fund President Prosecutor General Paweł Juszczyszyn National Prosecutor Łukasz Piebiak Constitution European Arrest Warrant Prime Minister freedom of expression Maciej Nawacki COVID-19 Marek Safjan Venice Commission Sejm immunity Criminal Chamber Regional Court in Kraków Iustitia Maciej Ferek Małgorzata Gersdorf reform Ministry of Justice NCJ Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber OSCE courts Wojciech Hermeliński disciplinary liability for judges EU budget corruption Stanisław Piotrowicz National Public Prosecutor criminal proceedings Council of Europe Anna Dalkowska LGBT Justice Fund President of the Republic of Poland Włodzimierz Wróbel conditionality mechanism THEMIS Krystian Markiewicz Aleksander Stepkowski Stanisław Biernat PiS reforms Law and Justice commission on Russian influence Jarosław Dudzicz conditionality freedom of assembly President of Poland Chamber of Professional Liability Ordo Iuris media independence Didier Reynders Reczkowicz and Others v. Poland SLAPP Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation Broda and Bojara v Poland Xero Flor w Polsce Sp. z o.o. v. Poland Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Supreme Court President Marcin Romanowski electoral code Andrzej Stępka Article 7 Piotr Prusinowski Senate Sylwia Gregorczyk-Abram Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe TVP media Lech Garlicki Lex Super Omnia police abortion Next Generation EU Ursula von der Leyen EAW Justice Defence Committee – KOS Amsterdam District Court defamation Krzysztof Parchimowicz Freedom House Michał Wawrykiewicz Ewa Łętowska Article 6 ECHR May 10 2020 elections 2017 Piotr Gąciarek Pegasus suspension P 7/20 acting first president of the Supreme Court National Electoral Commission K 7/21 PM Mateusz Morawiecki Andrzej Zoll Jarosław Wyrembak Lex Duda Professional Liability Chamber Civil Chamber parliament civil society National Reconstruction Plan Constitutional Tribunal President Adam Jamróz Stefan Jaworski Joanna Hetnarowicz-Sikora Kraków Biruta Lewaszkiewicz-Petrykowska Stanisław Rymar Małgorzata Pyziak- Szafnicka Janusz Niemcewicz Andrzej Mączyński Marek Mazurkiewicz Adam Synakiewicz state of emergency Wojciech Łączkowski Edyta Barańska Mirosław Granat Kazimierz Działocha Joanna Misztal-Konecka judcial independence Maciej Mitera Dariusz Korneluk Viktor Orban OLAF restoration of the rule of law veto Mariusz Kamiński surveillance K 6/21 Józef Iwulski Astradsson v Iceland Central Anti-Corruption Bureau PATFox SLAPPs Teresa Dębowska-Romanowska accountability Ukraine Krystyna Pawłowicz Rafał Puchalski transparency Dariusz Zawistowski OKO.press right to fair trial Dariusz Drajewicz Paweł Filipek Maciej Taborowski smear campaign insulting religious feelings National Prosecutor’s Office Mariusz Muszyński Belarus electoral process court presidents Marzanna Piekarska-Drążek milestones Wojciech Maczuga Michał Laskowski Marian Banaś Jakub Iwaniec Sławomira Wronkowska-Jaśkiewicz Piotr Tuleja Jerzy Stępień elections fairness Andrzej Rzepliński Szymon Szynkowski vel Sęk Ferdynand Rymarz International Criminal Court Marek Pietruszyński Mirosław Wyrzykowski Bohdan Zdziennicki Xero Flor v. Poland public media Supreme Audit Office lexTusk court changes elections integrity Marek Zubik Konrad Wytrykowski abuse of state resources General Assembly of the Supreme Court Judges European Parliament Zuzanna Rudzińska-Bluszcz Marcin Warchoł 11 January March in Warsaw European Association of Judges Ziobro Free Courts decommunization Ewa Wrzosek EU law primacy human rights Piebiak gate recommendation report Law on the NCJ lex NGO Russia CCBE public opinion poll Human Rights Commissioner Jarosław Gowin Piotr Pszczółkowski LGBT ideology free zones C-791/19 coronavirus criminal code retirement age Netherlands Adam Tomczyński democratic backsliding intimidation of dissenters The Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe Bogdan Święczkowski transfer Belgium Joanna Scheuring-Wielgus Nations in Transit Council of the EU Elżbieta Jabłońska-Malik Katarzyna Chmura Sebastian Mazurek Jędrzej Dessoulavy-Śliwiński LIBE Committee defamatory statements Małgorzata Fronc Rafał Lisak Karolina Miklaszewska NGO Krystyna Morawa-Fryźlewicz Irena Bochniak opposition European Court of Hu electoral commissions Act on the Supreme Court discrimination Jakub Kwieciński World Justice Project award Tomasz Koszewski test of independence Dariusz Dończyk Grzegorz Furmankiewicz Antykasta Stanisław Zdun Adam Gendźwiłł 2018 Wojciech Sadurski Full-Scale Election Observation Mission ODIHR Marek Jaskulski repairing the rule of law advocate general press release Follow the Money #RecoveryFiles media pluralism Michał Dworczyk Dworczyk leaks E-mail scandal Andrzej Skowron Rights and Values Programme Tomasz Szmydt Łukasz Biliński Ivan Mischenko Monika Frąckowiak Emilia Szmydt Swieczkowski Kasta/Antykasta Bohdan Bieniek Stanisław Zabłocki Joanna Kołodziej-Michałowicz Petros Tovmasyan Jerzy Kwaśniewski Piotr Mazurek Grzegorz Puda National Recovery Plan Monitoring Committee Wiesław Kozielewicz Frans Timmermans Małgorzata Dobiecka-Woźniak US Department of State Marcin Krajewski Ewa Łąpińska Zbigniew Łupina Paweł Styrna C-619/18 Arkadiusz Cichocki CT President Marcin Matczak equal treatment National School of Judiciary and Public Prosecution (KSSiP)codification commission delegations Watchdog Polska Dariusz Barski Lasota fundamental rights State Tribunal insult civil law Radosław Baszuk Action Plan Justice Ministry Věra Jourová Donald Tusk justice system reform Anti-SLAPP Directive Hater Scandal populism National Council for the Judiciary civil partnerships bill KRS Judicial Reforms migration strategy Penal Code LGBTQ+NIK Profeto same-sex unions Katarzyna Kotula civil partnerships Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights Piotr Hofmański C‑718/21 preliminary reference EU law ethics Chamber of Professional Responsibility The Codification Committee of Civil Law Investigation Poznań Krzysztof Rączka extraordinary commission Zbigniew Kapiński Anna Głowacka Court of Appeal in Warsaw Osiatyński'a Archive transitional justice US State Department Assessment Act Crimes of espionage Joanna Knobel Agnieszka Brygidyr-Dorosz Koan Lenaerts Karol Weitz Kaspryszyn v Poland NCR&D NCBiR The National Centre for Research and Development European Anti-Fraud Office OLAF Justyna Wydrzyńska environment investment strategic investment Rafał Wojciechowski Aleksandra Rutkowska General Court of the EU Arkadiusz Radwan Lech Wałęsa Wałęsa v. Poland right to an independent and impartial tribunal established by law pilot-judgment Dobrochna Bach-Golecka election fairness National Broadcasting Council gag lawsuits lex Raczkowski Piotr Raczkowski the Spy Act disinformation lustration White Paper EU Donald Tusk government judge Przemysław Czarnek József Szájer Rafał Trzaskowski Klubrádió Sobczyńska and Others v Poland Żurek v Poland Gazeta Wyborcza Grzęda v Poland Pollityka Jelen media law Index.hu Jacek Czaputowicz Elżbieta Karska Przemysła Radzik media tax advertising tax mediabezwyboru Jacek Kurski KESMA Brussels I Rome II LGBT free zones First President of the Suprme Court Bogdan Świączkowski Disicplinary Chamber Tribunal of State Organization of Security and Co-operation in Europe Olsztyn court Przemysła Czarnek equality Marek Piertuszyński Chamber of Extraordinary Verification Article 2 Forum shopping hate speech Sebastian Kaleta hate crimes C-156/21 C-157/21 Education Minister the Regional Court in Warsaw protests the Netherlands Denmark Sweden Finland Mariusz Krasoń Germany Celmer mutual trust abortion ruling LM United Nations Leszek Mazur Amsterdam Irena Majcher interim measures Ireland autocratization Multiannual Financial Framework C354/20 PPU C412/20 PPU C-487/19 Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs Norwegian funds Norway Kraśnik Ombudsman Zbigniew Boniek ENA Article 10 ECHR Regional Court in Amsterdam Openbaar Ministerie Ausl 301 AR 104/19 Karlsruhe act on misdemeanours Civil Service Act public broadcaster Forum Współpracy Sędziów Simpson judgment AK judgment legislative practice foreign agents law repressive act Maciej Czajka Mariusz Jałoszewski Łukasz Radke polexit LSO trans-Atlantic values Dolińska-Ficek and Ozimek v Poland Amnesty International The First President of the Supreme Court Ernest Bejda Jacek Sasin right to protest Sławomir Jęksa Wiktor Joachimkowski Roman Giertych Act of 20 December 2019 Michał Woś Ministry of Finance lawyers Frackowiak Paulina Kieszkowska-Knapik Kochenov Paulina Aslanowicz Jarosław Matras Małgorzata Wąsek-Wiaderek ct on the Protection of the Populatio Pech legislation lex Woś Kaczyński Putinism Court of Appeal in Kraków Maria Ejchart-Dubois Agreement for the Rule of Law Porozumienie dla Praworządności Act sanitising the judiciary ECJ Marek Ast Freedom in the World Evgeni Tanchev Rome Statute Israel European Public Prosecutor's Office EU values Polish National Foundation Lux Veritatis infringment action Małgorzata Bednarek Piotr Wawrzyk PKW ENCJ oligarchic system clientelism Ipsos Olimpia Barańska-Małusze Hudoc Konrad Szymański Piotr Bogdanowicz Piotr Buras authoritarian equilibrium Article 258 Leon Kieres resolution of 23 January 2020 Telex.hu EU treaties Agnieszka Niklas-Bibik Słupsk Regional Court Alina Czubieniak Maciej Rutkiewicz harrassment Mirosław Wróblewski primacy border Gerard Birgfeller TVN journalists lexTVN postal vote bill Polish media postal vote Ewa Maciejewska Rzeszów Koen Lenaerts

Other articles by this author

March 24, 2024

ECtHR: the meeting schedule of the Constitutional Tribunal President is public information

August 25, 2023

Prosecution of Bydgoszcz judges by Radzik. The president will not intervene. ‘Premature and unauthorised’

August 25, 2023

Extraordinary meeting of the new National Council for Judiciary. ‘A tribute of surrender’.

August 25, 2023

PiS spy law has been passed. ‘An open door for striking at journalists and not only’

June 28, 2023

Electoral pathologies. How the PiS authorities are reducing the chances of the parties

June 19, 2023

The government has prepared an attack on local governments and a muzzle for naturalists in one bill. The Assessment Act in the Sejm

June 1, 2023

Retired Constitutional Tribunal Judges on ‘lex Tusk’: This act of exceptional evil violates the principles of the rule of law, human and civil rights

May 24, 2023

Illegal interference with final rulings. 43 judges of the Court of Appeal in Warsaw protest

April 23, 2023

The commission on Russian influence can sentence someone to public lynching. The citizen is completely defenceless [interview]

April 23, 2023

The Law and Justice party wants harsher penalties for betraying the homeland. Even life imprisonment for espionage