Tag: Venice Commission

Venice Commission opinion on the “muzzle law”

author

Rule of Law

date

17 January 2020

Venice Commission opinion on the “muzzle law”

“The amendments of December 2019 diminish judicial independence and put Polish judges into the impossible situation of having to face disciplinary proceedings for decisions required by the ECHR, the law of the European Union, and other international instruments.”

Incredible official position of the Ministry of Justice regarding the opinion of the Venice Commission

author

Rule of Law

date

17 January 2020

Incredible official position of the Ministry of Justice regarding the opinion of the Venice Commission

We publish the translation of the opinion published on the Ministry of Justice website for consideration of Rule of Law in Poland readers. This is of course not endorsement.

The rule of law in Poland Actions by EU institutions and unaddressed recommendations of the European Commission

author

Maria Ejchart-Dubois

date

6 March 2019

The rule of law in Poland Actions by EU institutions and unaddressed recommendations of the European Commission

Provisions subordinating the judiciary to the executive (including disciplinary proceedings against judges), which are completely incompatible with European standards, are still in place.

Tags

Supreme Court Disciplinary Chamber Constitutional Tribunal judges disciplinary proceedings Poland Zbigniew Ziobro Court of Justice of the EU rule of law European Commission National Council of the Judiciary judicial independence Małgorzata Manowska Andrzej Duda European Union Court of Justice Igor Tuleya disciplinary system European Court of Human Rights Jarosław Kaczyński Mateusz Morawiecki Minister of Justice muzzle law CJEU Commissioner for Human Rights National Recovery Plan Waldemar Żurek Przemysław Radzik democracy presidential elections Kamil Zaradkiewicz disciplinary commissioner Piotr Schab neo-judges judiciary First President of the Supreme Court Adam Bodnar preliminary rulings Supreme Administrative Court Hungary criminal law elections 2020 elections media freedom K 3/21 Dagmara Pawełczyk-Woicka National Council for Judiciary harassment Julia Przyłębska prosecutors Łukasz Piebiak Michał Lasota Beata Morawiec Paweł Juszczyszyn elections 2023 Prime Minister President Prosecutor General Constitution COVID-19 European Arrest Warrant Maciej Nawacki Criminal Chamber Regional Court in Kraków Recovery Fund Court of Justice of the European Union Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber EU budget freedom of expression disciplinary liability for judges Wojciech Hermeliński Małgorzata Gersdorf Sejm Maciej Ferek freedom of assembly conditionality Law and Justice prosecution NCJ Ministry of Justice National Prosecutor PiS Stanisław Piotrowicz Marek Safjan Aleksander Stepkowski OSCE President of the Republic of Poland immunity Anna Dalkowska National Public Prosecutor Council of Europe criminal proceedings Stanisław Biernat conditionality mechanism Włodzimierz Wróbel commission on Russian influence 2017 police Justice Defence Committee – KOS Freedom House Supreme Court President Article 7 Venice Commission PM Mateusz Morawiecki Justice Fund National Electoral Commission Jarosław Wyrembak Andrzej Zoll acting first president of the Supreme Court Ordo Iuris May 10 2020 elections President of Poland LGBT Xero Flor w Polsce Sp. z o.o. v. Poland Broda and Bojara v Poland Reczkowicz and Others v. Poland media independence Iustitia Krystian Markiewicz Sylwia Gregorczyk-Abram Amsterdam District Court courts Krzysztof Parchimowicz Michał Wawrykiewicz Article 6 ECHR THEMIS EAW Ursula von der Leyen TVP media Lech Garlicki Ewa Łętowska Andrzej Stępka Piotr Gąciarek corruption P 7/20 K 7/21 Lex Duda National Reconstruction Plan Professional Liability Chamber suspension parliament Jarosław Dudzicz Chamber of Professional Liability Piotr Prusinowski democratic backsliding decommunization Law on the NCJ recommendation Human Rights Commissioner CCBE The Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe public opinion poll report European Parliament Ziobro intimidation of dissenters transfer retirement age Piebiak gate human rights European Association of Judges 11 January March in Warsaw coronavirus C-791/19 Piotr Pszczółkowski General Assembly of the Supreme Court Judges lex NGO civil society Russia Jarosław Gowin LGBT ideology free zones criminal code Senate Zuzanna Rudzińska-Bluszcz Marcin Warchoł defamation Free Courts Ewa Wrzosek EU law primacy Lex Super Omnia Adam Tomczyński Belgium Netherlands Bogdan Święczkowski judcial independence Maciej Mitera Viktor Orban OLAF Next Generation EU veto abortion Józef Iwulski Teresa Dębowska-Romanowska Kazimierz Działocha Mirosław Granat Adam Jamróz Stefan Jaworski Biruta Lewaszkiewicz-Petrykowska Wojciech Łączkowski Marek Mazurkiewicz Andrzej Mączyński Janusz Niemcewicz Małgorzata Pyziak- Szafnicka Stanisław Rymar Ferdynand Rymarz Andrzej Rzepliński Jerzy Stępień Piotr Tuleja Sławomira Wronkowska-Jaśkiewicz Mirosław Wyrzykowski Bohdan Zdziennicki Marek Zubik Didier Reynders SLAPP OKO.press Dariusz Zawistowski Michał Laskowski Marek Pietruszyński Krystyna Pawłowicz Mariusz Muszyński Paweł Filipek Maciej Taborowski Marian Banaś Supreme Audit Office Adam Synakiewicz Belarus state of emergency Kraków Xero Flor v. Poland Astradsson v Iceland K 6/21 Civil Chamber Joanna Misztal-Konecka Pegasus Mariusz Kamiński surveillance Central Anti-Corruption Bureau Joanna Hetnarowicz-Sikora Edyta Barańska Ukraine Konrad Wytrykowski Jakub Iwaniec Dariusz Drajewicz Rafał Puchalski smear campaign milestones Constitutional Tribunal President Marzanna Piekarska-Drążek electoral process Wojciech Maczuga lexTusk court changes populism equal treatment fundamental rights CT President EU White Paper lustration transitional justice 2018 Nations in Transit Council of the EU Stanisław Zabłocki LIBE Committee Frans Timmermans US Department of State Swieczkowski advocate general press release Rights and Values Programme C-619/18 defamatory statements World Justice Project award Wojciech Sadurski judge Pech Kochenov Evgeni Tanchev Freedom in the World ECJ Frackowiak Amnesty International trans-Atlantic values LSO lawyers Act of 20 December 2019 repressive act Koen Lenaerts harrassment Alina Czubieniak Gerard Birgfeller Ewa Maciejewska postal vote postal vote bill resolution of 23 January 2020 Leon Kieres PKW infringment action EU values ENCJ Israel foreign agents law Organization of Security and Co-operation in Europe First President of the Suprme Court LGBT free zones equality Chamber of Extraordinary Verification hate crimes hate speech Grzęda v Poland Żurek v Poland Sobczyńska and Others v Poland Rafał Trzaskowski media law Przemysła Radzik Elżbieta Karska Marcin Romanowski Jacek Czaputowicz Przemysław Czarnek legislative practice ENA Zbigniew Boniek Ombudsman Kraśnik Norway Norwegian funds Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs C-487/19 Article 10 ECHR Regional Court in Amsterdam Openbaar Ministerie AK judgment Simpson judgment Forum Współpracy Sędziów public broadcaster mutual trust LM Ireland Irena Majcher Amsterdam the Regional Court in Warsaw United Nations Leszek Mazur interim measures autocratization Multiannual Financial Framework abortion ruling protests the Netherlands Denmark Sweden Finland Mariusz Krasoń Germany Celmer C354/20 PPU C412/20 PPU Ausl 301 AR 104/19 Karlsruhe act on misdemeanours Civil Service Act Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe media tax advertising tax mediabezwyboru Jacek Kurski KESMA Index.hu Telex.hu Jelen József Szájer Klubrádió Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation Gazeta Wyborcza Pollityka Brussels I Rome II Article 2 Forum shopping transparency Sebastian Kaleta C-156/21 C-157/21 Marek Piertuszyński National Prosecutor’s Office Bogdan Świączkowski Disicplinary Chamber Tribunal of State Olsztyn court Przemysła Czarnek Education Minister Ipsos Olimpia Barańska-Małusze Hudoc Konrad Szymański Piotr Bogdanowicz Piotr Buras authoritarian equilibrium Article 258 clientelism oligarchic system European Public Prosecutor's Office Polish National Foundation Lux Veritatis Małgorzata Bednarek Piotr Wawrzyk TVN journalists lexTVN Polish media Rzeszów border primacy EU treaties Agnieszka Niklas-Bibik Słupsk Regional Court Maciej Rutkiewicz Mirosław Wróblewski right to protest Sławomir Jęksa Wiktor Joachimkowski Roman Giertych Michał Woś Ministry of Finance Jacek Sasin Ernest Bejda The First President of the Supreme Court Maciej Czajka Mariusz Jałoszewski Łukasz Radke polexit Dolińska-Ficek and Ozimek v Poland Paulina Kieszkowska-Knapik Maria Ejchart-Dubois Agreement for the Rule of Law Porozumienie dla Praworządności Act sanitising the judiciary Marek Ast Court of Appeal in Kraków Putinism Kaczyński right to fair trial Paulina Aslanowicz Jarosław Matras Małgorzata Wąsek-Wiaderek ct on the Protection of the Populatio legislation lex Woś Rome Statute International Criminal Court Antykasta Stanisław Zdun Irena Bochniak Krystyna Morawa-Fryźlewicz Katarzyna Chmura Grzegorz Furmankiewicz Marek Jaskulski Joanna Kołodziej-Michałowicz Ewa Łąpińska Zbigniew Łupina Paweł Styrna Kasta/Antykasta Andrzej Skowron Łukasz Biliński Ivan Mischenko Monika Frąckowiak Arkadiusz Cichocki Emilia Szmydt Tomasz Szmydt E-mail scandal Dworczyk leaks Michał Dworczyk media pluralism #RecoveryFiles Follow the Money repairing the rule of law Bohdan Bieniek Marcin Krajewski Małgorzata Dobiecka-Woźniak Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Wiesław Kozielewicz National Recovery Plan Monitoring Committee Grzegorz Puda Piotr Mazurek Jerzy Kwaśniewski Petros Tovmasyan court presidents ODIHR Full-Scale Election Observation Mission NGO Karolina Miklaszewska Rafał Lisak Małgorzata Fronc Jędrzej Dessoulavy-Śliwiński Sebastian Mazurek Elżbieta Jabłońska-Malik Szymon Szynkowski vel Sęk Joanna Scheuring-Wielgus insulting religious feelings opposition electoral code Adam Gendźwiłł Dariusz Dończyk test of independence Tomasz Koszewski public media Jakub Kwieciński discrimination Act on the Supreme Court electoral commissions European Court of Hu Krzysztof Rączka Poznań Koan Lenaerts Karol Weitz Kaspryszyn v Poland NCR&D NCBiR The National Centre for Research and Development European Anti-Fraud Office OLAF Justyna Wydrzyńska Agnieszka Brygidyr-Dorosz Joanna Knobel Crimes of espionage extraordinary commission Zbigniew Kapiński Anna Głowacka Court of Appeal in Warsaw Osiatyński'a Archive US State Department Assessment Act environment investment strategic investment gag lawsuits lex Raczkowski Piotr Raczkowski the Spy Act disinformation

12.09.2023

PiS will not remove Judge Raczkowski in silence. An application will be filed with the European Commission and the ECtHR.

Mariusz Jałoszewski - 12.09.2023

Tag: Venice Commission

Venice Commission opinion on the “muzzle law”

Rule of Law

Venice Commission opinion on the “muzzle law”

Incredible official position of the Ministry of Justice regarding the opinion of the Venice Commission

Rule of Law

Incredible official position of the Ministry of Justice regarding the opinion of the Venice Commission

The rule of law in Poland Actions by EU institutions and unaddressed recommendations of the European Commission

Maria Ejchart-Dubois

The rule of law in Poland Actions by EU institutions and unaddressed recommendations of the European Commission

Tags

Newest posts

PiS Threatens to Take Over Courts, Liquidate Supreme Court, and Challenge CJEU

Kaczyński announces the takeover of the courts after the elections. He threatens: ‘No one will stop us’

Prosecution of Bydgoszcz judges by Radzik. The president will not intervene. ‘Premature and unauthorised’

Extraordinary meeting of the new National Council for Judiciary. ‘A tribute of surrender’.

PiS spy law has been passed. ‘An open door for striking at journalists and not only’

PiS will not remove Judge Raczkowski in silence. An application will be filed with the European Commission and the ECtHR.

PiS Threatens to Take Over Courts, Liquidate Supreme Court, and Challenge CJEU

Kaczyński announces the takeover of the courts after the elections. He threatens: ‘No one will stop us’

Prosecution of Bydgoszcz judges by Radzik. The president will not intervene. ‘Premature and unauthorised’

Extraordinary meeting of the new National Council for Judiciary. ‘A tribute of surrender’.

PiS spy law has been passed. ‘An open door for striking at journalists and not only’

PiS will not remove Judge Raczkowski in silence. An application will be filed with the European Commission and the ECtHR.