Statement of Supreme Court judges of 17 March 2021

Rule of Law

Everything you need to know about the rule of law in Poland

We obtained a statement of 65 active and former Supreme Court judges regarding requests to lift judicial immunity and the Disciplinary Chamber

[Download PDF]

We, the undersigned Supreme Court judges, oppose the practice of the Prosecutor’s Office of requesting for authorisation for criminal prosecution of judges based on allegations related to decision-making process and execution of judgments by the court’s staff. The alleged crimes committed by judges are not supported by compelling evidence. Moreover, the requests for waiver of judicial immunity are directed against judges who publicly express negative opinions about the state of the rule of law in Poland.

We oppose hearing the mentioned requests by the Disciplinary Chamber – a body whose independence and impartiality have been effectively compromised in the case-law of the Court of Justice, the Supreme Court, and ordinary courts. The Disciplinary Chamber ought to refrain from processing all cases pending before it until delivery of the final judgment of the Court of Justice.

The practice of requesting for waiver of judicial immunity shows how law can be exploited to discredit judges who express their criticism over changes in the justice system. At the same time, it is an attempt to create a ‘chilling effect’ on other judges by discouraging them from issuing rulings that can be perceived by the authorities as unpleasant, and from defending the rule of law.

We would like to draw the attention of the domestic and international public to the sustained dismantlement of democracy and the rule of law in the Republic of Poland.

The following Supreme Court judges signed this statement until it was made public

Civil Chamber

Dariusz Zawistowski – President

Teresa Bielska-Sobkowicz

Dariusz Dończyk

Tadeusz Ereciński

Józef Frąckowiak

Jacek Gudowski

Irena Gromska-Szuster

Paweł Grzegorczyk

Wojciech Katner

Monika Koba

Marian Kocon

Iwona Koper

Anna Kozłowska

Zbigniew Kwaśniewski

Grzegorz Misiurek

Barbara Myszka

Anna Owczarek

Władysław Pawlak

Henryk Pietrzkowski

Krzysztof Pietrzykowski

Agnieszka Piotrowska

Marta Romańska

Krzysztof Strzelczyk

Maria Szulc

Roman Trzaskowski

Katarzyna Tyczka-Rote

Bogumiła Ustjanicz

Karol Weitz

Tadeusz Wiśniewski

Kazimierz Zawada

Tadeusz Żyznowski

Criminal Chamber

Michał Laskowski – President

Stanisław Zabłocki

Tomasz Artymiuk

Jacek Błaszczyk

Krzysztof Cesarz

Małgorzata Gierszon

Jerzy Grubba

Przemysław Kalinowski

Jarosław Matras

Waldemar Płóciennik

Zbigniew Puszkarski

Andrzej Siuchniński

Barbara Skoczkowska

Dariusz Świecki

Małgorzata Wąsek-Wiaderek

Eugeniusz Wildowicz

Paweł Wiliński

Labour and Social Security Chamber

Józef Iwulski – President

Małgorzata Gersdorf

Teresa Flemming-Kulesza

Bohdan Bieniek

Jolanta Frańczak

Katarzyna Gonera

Beata Gudowska

Halina Kiryło

Roman Kuczyński

Jerzy Kuźniar

Dawid Miąsik

Maciej Pacuda

Piotr Prusinowski

Krzysztof Rączka

Romualda Spyt

Małgorzata Wrębiakowska-Marzec

Andrzej Wróbel

Author

Rule of Law

Everything you need to know about the rule of law in Poland

Published

March 17, 2021

Tags

Supreme Court Poland Constitutional Tribunal Disciplinary Chamber judges rule of law disciplinary proceedings Zbigniew Ziobro National Council of the Judiciary Court of Justice of the EU judicial independence European Commission European Union Andrzej Duda Małgorzata Manowska Court of Justice Minister of Justice European Court of Human Rights Adam Bodnar Igor Tuleya disciplinary system muzzle law Jarosław Kaczyński National Recovery Plan CJEU Mateusz Morawiecki neo-judges Commissioner for Human Rights Court of Justice of the European Union Przemysław Radzik Waldemar Żurek democracy National Council for Judiciary Piotr Schab elections presidential elections Kamil Zaradkiewicz Julia Przyłębska media freedom criminal law elections 2023 disciplinary commissioner harassment prosecution Supreme Administrative Court Hungary elections 2020 preliminary rulings judiciary Dagmara Pawełczyk-Woicka K 3/21 First President of the Supreme Court Paweł Juszczyszyn National Prosecutor Recovery Fund President Michał Lasota Prosecutor General Łukasz Piebiak Beata Morawiec prosecutors European Arrest Warrant freedom of expression Constitution Prime Minister Sejm immunity Maciej Nawacki Iustitia Regional Court in Kraków Criminal Chamber COVID-19 Maciej Ferek OSCE Małgorzata Gersdorf courts Venice Commission Marek Safjan Ministry of Justice Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber EU budget disciplinary liability for judges Wojciech Hermeliński PiS NCJ Krystian Markiewicz Stanisław Piotrowicz President of the Republic of Poland Aleksander Stepkowski commission on Russian influence Justice Fund THEMIS Law and Justice National Public Prosecutor Council of Europe criminal proceedings conditionality corruption Stanisław Biernat reforms Anna Dalkowska freedom of assembly conditionality mechanism Włodzimierz Wróbel suspension Piotr Gąciarek Ordo Iuris Reczkowicz and Others v. Poland parliament Marcin Romanowski Andrzej Stępka media independence Chamber of Professional Liability Broda and Bojara v Poland Xero Flor w Polsce Sp. z o.o. v. Poland P 7/20 K 7/21 LGBT President of Poland National Reconstruction Plan Jarosław Dudzicz Lex Duda Professional Liability Chamber May 10 2020 elections Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation Piotr Prusinowski defamation Lex Super Omnia media Ursula von der Leyen Krzysztof Parchimowicz EAW abortion Michał Wawrykiewicz electoral code Amsterdam District Court Next Generation EU SLAPP Constitutional Tribunal President Didier Reynders TVP Ewa Łętowska Senate Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe Lech Garlicki Sylwia Gregorczyk-Abram Article 6 ECHR Andrzej Zoll National Electoral Commission Freedom House Jarosław Wyrembak Justice Defence Committee – KOS reform Article 7 acting first president of the Supreme Court Supreme Court President 2017 PM Mateusz Morawiecki police Piotr Tuleja Jerzy Stępień Andrzej Rzepliński Ferdynand Rymarz Stanisław Rymar Małgorzata Pyziak- Szafnicka Dariusz Zawistowski OKO.press report Sławomira Wronkowska-Jaśkiewicz Mirosław Wyrzykowski Marek Zubik Dariusz Korneluk Marzanna Piekarska-Drążek European Parliament milestones electoral process Andrzej Mączyński Józef Iwulski Wojciech Maczuga veto OLAF Viktor Orban Szymon Szynkowski vel Sęk Maciej Mitera judcial independence court presidents Janusz Niemcewicz Teresa Dębowska-Romanowska Marek Mazurkiewicz Ziobro Mirosław Granat Wojciech Łączkowski Biruta Lewaszkiewicz-Petrykowska Stefan Jaworski Adam Jamróz Kazimierz Działocha insulting religious feelings restoration of the rule of law right to fair trial Xero Flor v. Poland Law on the NCJ Kraków state of emergency decommunization Belarus Adam Synakiewicz Astradsson v Iceland K 6/21 Joanna Hetnarowicz-Sikora Central Anti-Corruption Bureau surveillance Mariusz Kamiński Pegasus Edyta Barańska Joanna Misztal-Konecka Civil Chamber Ukraine Supreme Audit Office Marian Banaś Krystyna Pawłowicz CCBE Rafał Puchalski The Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe Marek Pietruszyński Michał Laskowski public opinion poll smear campaign Mariusz Muszyński Human Rights Commissioner Maciej Taborowski Paweł Filipek International Criminal Court Konrad Wytrykowski recommendation accountability Jakub Iwaniec Dariusz Drajewicz transparency Free Courts Bohdan Zdziennicki retirement age SLAPPs PATFox LGBT ideology free zones lexTusk Adam Tomczyński 11 January March in Warsaw abuse of state resources European Association of Judges public media Ewa Wrzosek court changes C-791/19 democratic backsliding coronavirus human rights criminal code Piebiak gate elections fairness Zuzanna Rudzińska-Bluszcz Jarosław Gowin EU law primacy Piotr Pszczółkowski Belgium transfer Netherlands civil society Russia Bogdan Święczkowski elections integrity intimidation of dissenters Marcin Warchoł lex NGO General Assembly of the Supreme Court Judges Agnieszka Brygidyr-Dorosz Crimes of espionage NCBiR Joanna Knobel Kasta/Antykasta The National Centre for Research and Development Hater Scandal Paweł Styrna Grzegorz Furmankiewicz Dariusz Barski Joanna Kołodziej-Michałowicz Justyna Wydrzyńska Krystyna Morawa-Fryźlewicz Ewa Łąpińska Irena Bochniak Zbigniew Łupina National Broadcasting Council Katarzyna Chmura Stanisław Zdun Lasota Antykasta European Anti-Fraud Office OLAF Marek Jaskulski Rome Statute Court of Appeal in Warsaw lex Raczkowski Court of Appeal in Kraków National Council for the Judiciary Marek Ast gag lawsuits Assessment Act Act sanitising the judiciary environment Porozumienie dla Praworządności Agreement for the Rule of Law Maria Ejchart-Dubois Paulina Kieszkowska-Knapik strategic investment Piotr Hofmański US State Department Putinism Kaczyński lex Woś disinformation extraordinary commission legislation the Spy Act Zbigniew Kapiński Anna Głowacka Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights investment Małgorzata Wąsek-Wiaderek Osiatyński'a Archive Jarosław Matras Paulina Aslanowicz Piotr Raczkowski ct on the Protection of the Populatio Andrzej Skowron opposition Dariusz Dończyk Petros Tovmasyan Jerzy Kwaśniewski Piotr Mazurek Grzegorz Puda National Recovery Plan Monitoring Committee insult State Tribunal Donald Tusk government test of independence pilot-judgment Věra Jourová Tomasz Koszewski right to an independent and impartial tribunal established by law Jakub Kwieciński discrimination Anti-SLAPP Directive ODIHR civil law Donald Tusk Justice Ministry Joanna Scheuring-Wielgus Action Plan Adam Gendźwiłł Elżbieta Jabłońska-Malik Sebastian Mazurek justice system reform Jędrzej Dessoulavy-Śliwiński European Court of Hu Małgorzata Fronc Rafał Lisak Karolina Miklaszewska Radosław Baszuk NGO Full-Scale Election Observation Mission Wałęsa v. Poland Act on the Supreme Court Lech Wałęsa Michał Dworczyk Dworczyk leaks Aleksandra Rutkowska E-mail scandal Rafał Wojciechowski delegations Tomasz Szmydt Emilia Szmydt Watchdog Polska Arkadiusz Cichocki Kaspryszyn v Poland Dobrochna Bach-Golecka Monika Frąckowiak NCR&D election fairness Ivan Mischenko media pluralism #RecoveryFiles Follow the Money Wiesław Kozielewicz electoral commissions Marcin Matczak Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Małgorzata Dobiecka-Woźniak Arkadiusz Radwan Marcin Krajewski Bohdan Bieniek General Court of the EU Krzysztof Rączka repairing the rule of law Poznań National School of Judiciary and Public Prosecution (KSSiP)Koan Lenaerts codification commission Karol Weitz Łukasz Biliński PKW hate speech Grzęda v Poland Żurek v Poland Sobczyńska and Others v Poland Rafał Trzaskowski media law Przemysła Radzik Elżbieta Karska Jacek Czaputowicz hate crimes Chamber of Extraordinary Verification infringment action EU values ENCJ Israel foreign agents law Organization of Security and Co-operation in Europe First President of the Suprme Court LGBT free zones equality Przemysław Czarnek legislative practice AK judgment Simpson judgment public broadcaster mutual trust LM Ireland Irena Majcher Amsterdam the Regional Court in Warsaw Openbaar Ministerie Regional Court in Amsterdam ENA Zbigniew Boniek Ombudsman Kraśnik Norway Norwegian funds Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs C-487/19 Article 10 ECHR United Nations Leon Kieres populism LIBE Committee Frans Timmermans US Department of State Swieczkowski advocate general press release Rights and Values Programme C-619/18 defamatory statements Stanisław Zabłocki Council of the EU equal treatment fundamental rights CT President EU White Paper lustration transitional justice 2018 Nations in Transit World Justice Project award Wojciech Sadurski Act of 20 December 2019 repressive act Koen Lenaerts harrassment Alina Czubieniak Gerard Birgfeller Ewa Maciejewska postal vote postal vote bill lawyers LSO judge Pech Kochenov Evgeni Tanchev Freedom in the World ECJ Frackowiak Amnesty International trans-Atlantic values resolution of 23 January 2020 Olsztyn court oligarchic system European Public Prosecutor's Office Polish National Foundation Lux Veritatis Małgorzata Bednarek Piotr Wawrzyk TVN journalists lexTVN clientelism Article 258 Przemysła Czarnek Education Minister Ipsos Olimpia Barańska-Małusze Hudoc Konrad Szymański Piotr Bogdanowicz Piotr Buras authoritarian equilibrium Polish media Rzeszów Michał Woś Ministry of Finance Jacek Sasin Ernest Bejda The First President of the Supreme Court Maciej Czajka Mariusz Jałoszewski Łukasz Radke polexit Roman Giertych Wiktor Joachimkowski border primacy EU treaties Agnieszka Niklas-Bibik Słupsk Regional Court Maciej Rutkiewicz Mirosław Wróblewski right to protest Sławomir Jęksa Dolińska-Ficek and Ozimek v Poland Tribunal of State Leszek Mazur Celmer C354/20 PPU C412/20 PPU Ausl 301 AR 104/19 Karlsruhe act on misdemeanours Civil Service Act Forum Współpracy Sędziów media tax Germany Mariusz Krasoń interim measures autocratization Multiannual Financial Framework abortion ruling protests the Netherlands Denmark Sweden Finland advertising tax mediabezwyboru Article 2 Forum shopping Sebastian Kaleta C-156/21 C-157/21 Marek Piertuszyński National Prosecutor’s Office Bogdan Świączkowski Rome II Brussels I Jacek Kurski KESMA Index.hu Telex.hu Jelen József Szájer Klubrádió Gazeta Wyborcza Pollityka Disicplinary Chamber

The government has prepared an attack on local governments and a muzzle for naturalists in one bill. The Assessment Act in the Sejm

June 1, 2023

Retired Constitutional Tribunal Judges on ‘lex Tusk’: This act of exceptional evil violates the principles of the rule of law, human and civil rights

May 24, 2023

Illegal interference with final rulings. 43 judges of the Court of Appeal in Warsaw protest

April 23, 2023

The commission on Russian influence can sentence someone to public lynching. The citizen is completely defenceless [interview]

April 23, 2023