Sham constitutional tribunal declares Strasbourg court judgment ‘non-existent’ – Rule of Law

Sham constitutional tribunal declares Strasbourg court judgment ‘non-existent’

Share

Rule of Law

Everything you need to know about the rule of law in Poland

More

In response to a request to remove an unlawful judge from a bench, the Constitutional Tribunal decided that the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights concerning the Tribunal's composition is of no legal significance.

We have obtained an English translation of the decision which can be accessed here.

Author

Rule of Law

Everything you need to know about the rule of law in Poland

More

Published

June 17, 2021

Tags

Supreme Court Poland Disciplinary Chamber Constitutional Tribunal judges rule of law disciplinary proceedings National Council of the Judiciary Zbigniew Ziobro judicial independence Court of Justice of the EU European Commission European Union Małgorzata Manowska Andrzej Duda Court of Justice European Court of Human Rights Minister of Justice Adam Bodnar Igor Tuleya disciplinary system neo-judges CJEU muzzle law Jarosław Kaczyński National Recovery Plan Mateusz Morawiecki Court of Justice of the European Union Commissioner for Human Rights Waldemar Żurek Przemysław Radzik democracy National Council for Judiciary elections 2023 media freedom elections criminal law presidential elections Julia Przyłębska Kamil Zaradkiewicz Piotr Schab disciplinary commissioner judiciary elections 2020 Hungary Supreme Administrative Court prosecution preliminary rulings First President of the Supreme Court Dagmara Pawełczyk-Woicka K 3/21 harassment National Prosecutor Beata Morawiec Recovery Fund President Prosecutor General Michał Lasota Łukasz Piebiak Paweł Juszczyszyn prosecutors Marek Safjan immunity freedom of expression Maciej Nawacki Prime Minister Sejm Constitution Criminal Chamber COVID-19 Regional Court in Kraków Iustitia European Arrest Warrant reform disciplinary liability for judges OSCE Wojciech Hermeliński Venice Commission Maciej Ferek courts EU budget Małgorzata Gersdorf Ministry of Justice Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Chamber Krystian Markiewicz NCJ Justice Fund commission on Russian influence THEMIS LGBT PiS Stanisław Piotrowicz President of the Republic of Poland Law and Justice Jarosław Dudzicz conditionality corruption Aleksander Stepkowski Stanisław Biernat freedom of assembly criminal proceedings reforms conditionality mechanism Council of Europe Włodzimierz Wróbel National Public Prosecutor Anna Dalkowska Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe P 7/20 Andrzej Stępka Constitutional Tribunal President Piotr Gąciarek media independence Civil Chamber Reczkowicz and Others v. Poland May 10 2020 elections suspension Professional Liability Chamber President of Poland National Reconstruction Plan Lex Duda K 7/21 Xero Flor w Polsce Sp. z o.o. v. Poland Broda and Bojara v Poland parliament Senate Chamber of Professional Liability Piotr Prusinowski TVP abortion Next Generation EU Michał Wawrykiewicz Article 6 ECHR Lex Super Omnia media EAW Krzysztof Parchimowicz electoral code Lech Garlicki Sylwia Gregorczyk-Abram Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation Marcin Romanowski SLAPP Didier Reynders Ewa Łętowska Amsterdam District Court defamation Ursula von der Leyen Ordo Iuris Andrzej Zoll National Electoral Commission acting first president of the Supreme Court Freedom House Article 7 PM Mateusz Morawiecki Justice Defence Committee – KOS Jarosław Wyrembak 2017 police Supreme Court President accountability Mirosław Wyrzykowski Małgorzata Pyziak- Szafnicka Stanisław Rymar Ferdynand Rymarz Andrzej Rzepliński electoral process Jerzy Stępień Piotr Tuleja Supreme Audit Office Ziobro Sławomira Wronkowska-Jaśkiewicz OKO.press court presidents Wojciech Maczuga Bohdan Zdziennicki Marek Zubik restoration of the rule of law Janusz Niemcewicz insulting religious feelings intimidation of dissenters veto transfer Dariusz Zawistowski OLAF Viktor Orban public media Maciej Mitera Józef Iwulski Szymon Szynkowski vel Sęk Andrzej Mączyński Marek Mazurkiewicz Wojciech Łączkowski Biruta Lewaszkiewicz-Petrykowska Stefan Jaworski Adam Jamróz Mirosław Granat Kazimierz Działocha Teresa Dębowska-Romanowska judcial independence democratic backsliding Joanna Misztal-Konecka International Criminal Court K 6/21 Astradsson v Iceland Jakub Iwaniec Xero Flor v. Poland recommendation Kraków Ukraine Pegasus decommunization Joanna Hetnarowicz-Sikora Edyta Barańska right to fair trial Central Anti-Corruption Bureau Law on the NCJ surveillance Mariusz Kamiński state of emergency Belarus Adam Synakiewicz Krystyna Pawłowicz The Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe public opinion poll milestones Marek Pietruszyński Michał Laskowski report Marzanna Piekarska-Drążek smear campaign Mariusz Muszyński Dariusz Drajewicz Marian Banaś Maciej Taborowski Paweł Filipek Rafał Puchalski Konrad Wytrykowski Human Rights Commissioner CCBE transparency lex NGO Piebiak gate Zuzanna Rudzińska-Bluszcz LGBT ideology free zones elections integrity elections fairness Jarosław Gowin PATFox Marcin Warchoł human rights Adam Tomczyński General Assembly of the Supreme Court Judges Free Courts European Association of Judges European Parliament Piotr Pszczółkowski Ewa Wrzosek 11 January March in Warsaw criminal code court changes Belgium civil society Dariusz Korneluk abuse of state resources Bogdan Święczkowski Russia SLAPPs coronavirus C-791/19 EU law primacy lexTusk Netherlands retirement age environment E-mail scandal Wiesław Kozielewicz Joanna Kołodziej-Michałowicz Marek Jaskulski Osiatyński'a Archive Grzegorz Furmankiewicz Wałęsa v. Poland investment US State Department Tomasz Szmydt Ewa Łąpińska Ivan Mischenko Andrzej Skowron Assessment Act Kasta/Antykasta Chamber of Professional Responsibility Monika Frąckowiak Arkadiusz Cichocki The Codification Committee of Civil Law Emilia Szmydt Paweł Styrna Zbigniew Łupina civil partnerships Lech Wałęsa Katarzyna Chmura ct on the Protection of the Populatio Małgorzata Wąsek-Wiaderek Jarosław Matras Paulina Aslanowicz Kaczyński Putinism Court of Appeal in Kraków same-sex unions Rafał Wojciechowski civil partnerships bill KRS Dobrochna Bach-Golecka National Broadcasting Council Judicial Reforms Marek Ast election fairness Krystyna Morawa-Fryźlewicz legislation strategic investment Katarzyna Kotula Arkadiusz Radwan General Court of the EU Irena Bochniak Stanisław Zdun gag lawsuits Antykasta lex Raczkowski Aleksandra Rutkowska Piotr Raczkowski Łukasz Biliński the Spy Act disinformation Rome Statute lex Woś Act sanitising the judiciary pilot-judgment Jakub Kwieciński Karolina Miklaszewska Poznań Dariusz Barski Lasota insult Koan Lenaerts Anti-SLAPP Directive Karol Weitz Hater Scandal justice system reform Donald Tusk Kaspryszyn v Poland discrimination NCR&D NCBiR right to an independent and impartial tribunal established by law Věra Jourová Rafał Lisak Małgorzata Fronc Jędrzej Dessoulavy-Śliwiński National School of Judiciary and Public Prosecution (KSSiP)Act on the Supreme Court Marcin Matczak State Tribunal test of independence electoral commissions Dariusz Dończyk codification commission European Court of Hu delegations Adam Gendźwiłł Watchdog Polska opposition Krzysztof Rączka Joanna Scheuring-Wielgus Elżbieta Jabłońska-Malik Sebastian Mazurek The National Centre for Research and Development European Anti-Fraud Office OLAF Tomasz Koszewski civil law Marcin Krajewski Bohdan Bieniek C‑718/21 Zbigniew Kapiński preliminary reference repairing the rule of law EU law ethics Donald Tusk government Anna Głowacka Follow the Money #RecoveryFiles Court of Appeal in Warsaw media pluralism Michał Dworczyk extraordinary commission Małgorzata Dobiecka-Woźniak Radosław Baszuk Justice Ministry Justyna Wydrzyńska Action Plan NGO Full-Scale Election Observation Mission ODIHR National Council for the Judiciary Agnieszka Brygidyr-Dorosz Petros Tovmasyan Jerzy Kwaśniewski Piotr Mazurek Grzegorz Puda Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights National Recovery Plan Monitoring Committee Joanna Knobel Crimes of espionage Piotr Hofmański Dworczyk leaks EU values Grzęda v Poland Żurek v Poland Sobczyńska and Others v Poland Rafał Trzaskowski media law Przemysła Radzik Elżbieta Karska Jacek Czaputowicz Przemysław Czarnek hate speech hate crimes ENCJ Israel foreign agents law Wojciech Sadurski Organization of Security and Co-operation in Europe First President of the Suprme Court LGBT free zones equality Chamber of Extraordinary Verification legislative practice ENA Zbigniew Boniek Forum Współpracy Sędziów public broadcaster mutual trust LM Ireland Irena Majcher Amsterdam the Regional Court in Warsaw United Nations Simpson judgment AK judgment Ombudsman Kraśnik Norway Norwegian funds Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs C-487/19 Article 10 ECHR Regional Court in Amsterdam Openbaar Ministerie Leszek Mazur infringment action populism LIBE Committee Frans Timmermans US Department of State Swieczkowski advocate general press release Rights and Values Programme C-619/18 defamatory statements Stanisław Zabłocki Council of the EU equal treatment fundamental rights CT President EU White Paper lustration transitional justice 2018 Nations in Transit World Justice Project award judge Pech Koen Lenaerts harrassment Alina Czubieniak Gerard Birgfeller Ewa Maciejewska postal vote postal vote bill resolution of 23 January 2020 Leon Kieres repressive act Act of 20 December 2019 Kochenov Evgeni Tanchev Freedom in the World ECJ Frackowiak Amnesty International trans-Atlantic values LSO lawyers PKW Ipsos Lux Veritatis Małgorzata Bednarek Piotr Wawrzyk TVN journalists lexTVN Polish media Rzeszów border Polish National Foundation European Public Prosecutor's Office Olimpia Barańska-Małusze Hudoc Konrad Szymański Piotr Bogdanowicz Piotr Buras authoritarian equilibrium Article 258 clientelism oligarchic system primacy EU treaties Agnieszka Niklas-Bibik The First President of the Supreme Court Maciej Czajka Mariusz Jałoszewski Łukasz Radke polexit Dolińska-Ficek and Ozimek v Poland Paulina Kieszkowska-Knapik Maria Ejchart-Dubois Agreement for the Rule of Law Ernest Bejda Jacek Sasin Słupsk Regional Court Maciej Rutkiewicz Mirosław Wróblewski right to protest Sławomir Jęksa Wiktor Joachimkowski Roman Giertych Michał Woś Ministry of Finance Porozumienie dla Praworządności Education Minister interim measures C354/20 PPU C412/20 PPU Ausl 301 AR 104/19 Karlsruhe act on misdemeanours Civil Service Act media tax advertising tax mediabezwyboru Celmer Germany autocratization Multiannual Financial Framework abortion ruling protests the Netherlands Denmark Sweden Finland Mariusz Krasoń Jacek Kurski KESMA Index.hu Sebastian Kaleta C-156/21 C-157/21 Marek Piertuszyński National Prosecutor’s Office Bogdan Świączkowski Disicplinary Chamber Tribunal of State Olsztyn court Forum shopping Telex.hu Jelen József Szájer Klubrádió Gazeta Wyborcza Pollityka Brussels I Rome II Article 2 Przemysła Czarnek

Other articles by this author

March 24, 2024

ECtHR: the meeting schedule of the Constitutional Tribunal President is public information

August 25, 2023

Prosecution of Bydgoszcz judges by Radzik. The president will not intervene. ‘Premature and unauthorised’

August 25, 2023

Extraordinary meeting of the new National Council for Judiciary. ‘A tribute of surrender’.

August 25, 2023

PiS spy law has been passed. ‘An open door for striking at journalists and not only’

June 28, 2023

Electoral pathologies. How the PiS authorities are reducing the chances of the parties

June 19, 2023

The government has prepared an attack on local governments and a muzzle for naturalists in one bill. The Assessment Act in the Sejm

June 1, 2023

Retired Constitutional Tribunal Judges on ‘lex Tusk’: This act of exceptional evil violates the principles of the rule of law, human and civil rights

May 24, 2023

Illegal interference with final rulings. 43 judges of the Court of Appeal in Warsaw protest

April 23, 2023

The commission on Russian influence can sentence someone to public lynching. The citizen is completely defenceless [interview]

April 23, 2023

The Law and Justice party wants harsher penalties for betraying the homeland. Even life imprisonment for espionage